Family Resources
How to Prepare for a Night Nanny’s First Shift
The Pyxie team7 min read
You’ve hired a night nanny, and their first shift is approaching. You may be wondering what to have ready, how much to explain, and what the first handoff will look like.
Your caregiver needs to understand your baby’s current care, know where supplies are, and collaborate with you on how the night will work. You don’t need to establish a formal routine or become a newborn care expert before they arrive. Their specialized knowledge and experience is part of the support you’ve hired them to provide.
Whether your baby is already home or you’re preparing before the birth, the conversations below will help you get ready. Discuss what you can in advance, then allow time at the beginning of the first shift to review details together.
Your Night Nanny’s First-Shift Checklist
- Share the current care information. Gather the feeding plan, relevant instructions from your baby’s healthcare team, and important contact details.
- Walk through the space and supplies. Show your caregiver the baby’s safe sleep space, changing area, feeding supplies, and household essentials.
- Confirm the working arrangement. Review responsibilities, start and finish times, and where your caregiver will spend the night.
- Agree on when and how to wake you. Include feeding, questions that need immediate attention, and what to do in an emergency.
- Plan useful updates. Decide what to record and allow time within the agreed shift for evening and morning handoffs.
- Invite questions. Ask what your caregiver needs and what they would like to clarify.
- Use the Pyxie app to keep everyone on the same page!
Talk Through What Overnight Support Will Look Like
Start with what you’re hoping to get from overnight care. That might be more uninterrupted rest, support between breastfeeds, or help becoming comfortable with feeding, diapering, and settling your baby. Then talk through how that support will work in practice.
If you’re breastfeeding, discuss whether your caregiver will bring the baby to you or whether you’d prefer to feed in another room. Agree on what they’ll handle afterward, such as burping, changing, and settling.
If you’re pumping, clarify whether cleaning pump parts, preparing equipment for the next session, and storing expressed milk are included in their responsibilities.
If your caregiver will give bottles, review the current feeding plan together. Show them the bottles and nipples you’re using, where milk or formula is kept, and the preparation, labeling, and storage instructions they’ll need. Keep relevant references easy to find, such as the CDC’s guidance on breast milk storage and preparation and infant formula preparation and storage.
Share any feeding instructions from your baby’s healthcare team, including whether your baby needs to be woken for feeds. Questions about changing that guidance should go back to the healthcare team.
If you’re still deciding how to divide the night, let your caregiver know. You can talk through an arrangement that supports your feeding plan and makes room for rest.
Keep Essential Care Information Somewhere You Can Both Find It
A shared place to keep information, like the Pyxie app’s Care Book, makes it easier to find important details without searching through messages or relying on memory. Use a format you can both access and keep up to date.
Before the first shift, gather:
- Your baby’s basic information. Their name, date of birth, and any birth or discharge information relevant to current care.
- The current feeding plan. Breastfeeding, expressed milk, formula, or a combination, along with relevant instructions from your baby’s healthcare team.
- Medical information. Known allergies, current concerns, follow-up instructions, and any prescribed care that needs to be discussed within your caregiver’s agreed responsibilities.
- Contact details. Your pediatrician’s office and after-hours number, your home address, and emergency contacts.
- Household details. How to reach you overnight, entry instructions, and anything that affects access to the home.
Review this information together before your caregiver takes over. They may have questions or notice details you haven’t thought to include.
At the beginning of each shift, share when your baby was last fed, had a diaper change, and slept. Mention anything different about feeding, diapers, or settling, along with any concerns or new instructions from your baby’s healthcare team.
Questions to Ask Your Night Nanny
You may know what feels difficult without knowing what would help. Perhaps you’re unsure what to include in an overnight update, or you’d like someone to demonstrate a settling approach. These are useful questions to bring to your caregiver.
You can ask:
- “Could you walk us through how you’d organize the night around this feeding plan?”
- “What would you want us to tell you at the start of each shift?”
- “If you notice something different about feeding or settling, how will you share it?”
- “Could you show us the approach you’re using so we can try it, too?”
Let your caregiver know how you prefer to learn. You might appreciate a demonstration and a chance to practice, or a brief explanation followed by a written note you can revisit later.
Your caregiver can explain their suggestions and offer practical guidance within their training and agreed responsibilities. Share what feels comfortable, ask questions, and decide together what to try. Medical concerns and changes to prescribed care belong with your baby’s healthcare team.
Walk Through the Space and Supplies Together
Before buying extra equipment, ask your caregiver what they expect to need. Looking at what you already have can help you decide whether anything is missing.
At the beginning of the first shift, show them:
- The baby’s safe sleep space. Point out where spare sleepwear and fitted sheets are kept.
- The changing area. Show them diapers, wipes, cream, spare clothing, and where to put laundry and used diapers.
- Feeding supplies. Include bottles, nipples, pump parts, milk or formula, and the equipment used for preparation and cleaning.
- Care areas. Explain where feeding, changing, and any agreed bathing will happen.
- Household essentials. Cover bathroom access, lighting, temperature controls, pets, entry and exit procedures, and where they can keep their belongings.
Review the sleep setup together using the American Academy of Pediatrics’ safe-sleep guidance. The AAP recommends placing babies on their backs on a firm, flat sleep surface, with a fitted sheet and no loose bedding or soft objects.
The aim is a setup you both understand and can use comfortably. Small details, such as knowing which light to use or where clean bottles belong, can make the first night easier to navigate.
Confirm Responsibilities and When to Wake You
Review your work agreement before the first shift. Confirm start and finish times, with time for both handoffs included in the agreed shift.
Be specific about responsibilities, particularly washing bottles and pump parts, restocking supplies, baby laundry, or bathing. For example, “feeding support” could mean bringing the baby to you, giving an agreed bottle, cleaning equipment, or a combination of those tasks.
Discuss where your caregiver will spend the night and whether the arrangement involves staying awake throughout the shift or includes agreed rest periods. If rest is part of the arrangement, clarify when it is appropriate and provide a suitable place for them to rest.
Next, agree on how you’ll communicate overnight:
- When you’ll be woken for feeding or other planned involvement.
- Which questions can wait until morning and which concerns need immediate attention.
- How your caregiver will reach you if you’re asleep.
- What they should do if they cannot wake or otherwise contact you.
Review the emergency plan together, including access to a phone, your home address, how to get urgent help, and how you’ll be notified. Ask your caregiver to explain when they would need to involve you based on their training and the responsibilities you’ve agreed on.
Both of you should understand what the caregiver can handle independently and when you need to be involved.
Plan Overnight Updates and a Morning Handoff
Before the first night begins, decide what you’d like recorded and how you’ll review it.
Useful overnight notes may include feeding times and amounts when measured, diaper changes, sleep periods, settling approaches, and questions to discuss. Ask your caregiver what they normally document, then agree on a level of detail that helps you understand the night without creating unnecessary work.
Use the morning handoff to talk through anything that needs context. Your caregiver can explain what helped your baby settle, flag supplies that are running low, and share observations or questions you may want to discuss with your baby’s healthcare team.
Plan a check-in after the first few nights, too. You can review whether the feeding arrangement supports your rest, which updates are useful, and whether any responsibilities or household details need clarification. Ask how the arrangement is working for your caregiver and whether they have what they need.
You don’t need to wait for that check-in to raise a question. It simply gives you both a dedicated time to reflect and make adjustments.
Bring what you know about your baby, explain what matters to your family, and share where you’d welcome help. Your caregiver brings their own experience, observations, and practical guidance. The first night is a chance to begin putting those contributions together.
Save the checklist and use it to guide your first-shift conversation.

